
While beautiful interiors, gorgeous gardens, pretty views, and excellent amenities are all important attributes to one degree or another for making a perfect villa in Italy, sometimes what sets a property apart is not immediately obvious from a listing. Sometimes, only reviews from a previous guests can truly explain why a vacation rental in Italy deserves 5 stars.
Here are just five listings that received 5-star reviews in September 2026...

Barberino Val D'Elsa, Tuscany
2 bedrooms
1 bathroom
Sleeps up to four guests
From €89 per night
An incredibly cute rental in Tuscany with authentically Tuscan interiors, views over vineyards and rolling green hills, access to lovely grounds and a shared private swimming pool, and more just 1km from Barberino Val D'Elsa
“Very nice setting in the middle of the Chianti Region! Everything worked and we entered a clean appartement. Big pool to hang out and walking distance to the midcentury center. We got a lot of good advice from Concetta, taking care of everything. We highly recommend this place!!”
Christian B.
Haselau (Deutschland)

Monterchi, Tuscany
6 bedrooms
7 bathrooms
Sleeps up to twelve guests
From €270 per night
This grand and historic luxury villa in Tuscany boasts lush gardens, sweeping views over the famous Tuscan countryside, a private swimming pool and Jacuzzi, picture-perfect interiors, and offers peace and tranquility as well as easy access to Monterchi 5km away.
“I can’t say enough good things about Palazzo Rosadi. It was magical! I have stayed in other villas in the area and I can tell you firsthand that the location and views were spectacular.The villa itself combined Old world charm and modern convenience. Our host Rosado was so accommodating he made all feel at home. We had excellent chefs that came in to cook some delicious meals for us, the pool was so relaxing plus the weather spectacular! I wish I had booked it for longer!”
Sue H.
Park Ridge (United States)

Camerano, Piedmont
3 bedrooms
5 bathrooms
Sleeps up to five guests
From €181 per night
A cosy modern villa in Piedmont with spacious open-plan interiors, neat grounds with areas to dine and relax al fresco and a pond, and a wellness room indoors with a hot-tub, on top of a hill in Camerano, 5km from Soglio.
“A beautiful villa with all the amenities, in a secluded location, with amazing views. You can go on lovely walks from the villa. The owner is very friendly and is always there to help. The hot tub is fantastic. There are truffle fields in the valley. A small vineyard is within walking distance. A great place.”
Marc V.
(Nederland)

Costigliole D'Asti, Piedmont
1 bedroom
1 bathroom
Sleeps up to two guests
From €114 per night
This very sweet little unit in a building dating back to 1900 boasts welcoming and pretty modernised interiors with original features, access to a shared private swimming pool, and lush green surroundings, 2km from Costigliole d'Asti.
“A perfectly equipped vacation rental, located in a very quiet, idyllic setting. A super-friendly host—best wishes to you, Marijke! Within walking distance is a charming garden restaurant serving delicious Piedmontese cuisine. We had no trouble reaching Asti and Alba by public bus—you simply take the bus to the large parking lot in the nearby town, where you’ll also find plenty of shopping options. The picturesque surroundings with countless places to visit (Marijke has wonderful tips) and “Slow Food” restaurants really won us over. We’ll definitely be back.”
Andrea H.
Frankfurt (De)

Subbiano, Tuscany
5 bedrooms
6 bathrooms
Sleeps up to ten guests
From €285 per night
A charming stone villa in the Tuscan countryside with spacious grounds, authentic interiors, a private pool and hot-tub, and air-conditioning throughout, 3km from the village of Subbiano and easy day-trip distance from both Arezzo and Florence.
“We used the place in a group of 10 people and had a great time!
Quick sum up of the things, that we always want to know, when we book a house like this:
The kitchen is big enough and has 2 large fridges, a big stove and an oven. In addition to that a big barbecue and a stone pizza oven.
The pool is huge and has a lot of benches. There's a lso a fridge at the pool. The whirlpool is also nice and comfortable for up to 8 people. Make sure to inform the owner/the agency in advance, if you want to use the pool from the first day on! We didn't know that and had to wait a little.
Indoors and outdoors there's a large table and space for everyone for a shared meal. Indoors there's also couches to fit the whole group.
The rooms are nice, more than enough bathrooms and showers and the whole setting is very comfortable and gives of a nice and homey atmposphere.
AND: It's a well-paved road to reach the house, so also reachable with non-offroad cars ;)
BUT there's quite an amount of mosquitos, so make sure to bring candles and repellants.
All in all: Great stay, lovely owners -> fully recommended.”
Leonard P.
Heidelberg (De)